Scottish Parliament e-Brief
Issue 217, 27th September 2004

 

SECTION 1 - BUSINESS THIS WEEK

THE CHAMBER

Wednesday 29th September 2004

14:35 – 14:55

Ministerial Statement: Spending Review 2004

14:55 – 17:00

Executive Debate: Spending Review 2004

17:00 – 17:30

Member’s Business: Development of Edinburgh Airport (Margaret Smith (LIB DEM))

 

 

Thursday 30th September 2004

09:30 – 12:00

Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party Debate: Health Issues

12:00 – 12:30

First Minister's Question Time

14:00 – 15:00

Question Time:

·         Enterprise, Lifelong Learning and Transport;

·         Justice and Law Officers; and

·         General Questions

15:00 – 17:00

Stage 1 Debate: Emergency Workers (Scotland) Bill

17:00 – 17:30

Member’s Business: Increasing Gender Pay Gap (Sandra White (SNP))

 

IN COMMITTEE
This week’s likely highlights in the Committee Corridors include:
 

Tuesday 21st September 2004

AM

Local Government and Transport
 

Members continue taking evidence for their Inquiry into issues arising from the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001.  This week’s session takes place in Glasgow.
 

 

Audit
 

A busy meeting will receive a briefing from the Auditor General for Scotland on AGS reports on “Commissioning Community Care Services for Older People” and “Adapting to the future: management of community equipment and adaptations.”  The Committee will consider a response from the Clerk / Chief Executive of the Scottish Parliament to its 7th Report 2004 entitled “The 2002 03 Audit of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body”, as well as confirming its approach to the report by the Auditor General for Scotland entitled “Management of the Holyrood building project”.
  

 

Finance
 

The Committee takes evidence on broad water issues.
 

PM

European and External Relations
 

After choosing a new Convener, the Committee will take evidence for its Promoting Scotland worldwide Inquiry.
 

 

Health
 

Members take evidence from Stewart Maxwell (SNP) on his Prohibition of Smoking in Regulated Areas (Scotland) Bill.
 

 

Justice 2
 

Stage 1 evidence on the Fire (Scotland) Bill continues.
 

Wednesday 22nd September 2004

AM

Environment and Rural Development
 

No less than 3 panels of witnesses give Stage 1 evidence on the Water Services etc. (Scotland) Bill.
 

 

Education
 

The Committee will agree the remit for an inquiry into the school curriculum, before noting the Scottish Executive’s proposed school closure guidance and considering whether PE342, concerning school closures, can now be disposed of.
 

 

Communities
 

Members consider public petitions on TETRA communication masts.
 

 

Justice 1
 

The main items of business are evidence on the Inquiry into the effectiveness of rehabilitation programmes in prisons and consideration of whether to appoint an adviser on the proposed bill to protect children and prevent sexual offences.
 

 

Public Petitions
 

The Committee takes evidence from Minister for Education and Young People, Peter Peacock, on a current petition on an inquiry into past institutional child abuse.
 

 

SECTION 2 – NEWS

New rights for victims of crime
For the first time, victims of serious crime are to be informed of the perpetrator’s eligibility for home release or day release.

This is in addition to the opportunity for victims of serious crime to make representations to the Parole Board for Scotland when the prisoner is being considered for release on licence.

The new provisions, to take effect from 1st November, will ensure that victims can register for the Victim Notification Scheme.  This will give them information on home release and day release and allow them to be informed if the prisoner is transferred outwith Scotland, dies, escapes, or absconds.

This new provision and others are covered under Sections 16 and 17 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003 which makes provision for giving information to victims of serious crime about the offender who committed said crime.  These provisions will apply to the victims of certain crimes specified in a Scottish Statutory Instrument called the Victim Notification (Prescribed Offences) (Scotland) Order 2004. This includes sexual and non-sexual crimes of violence; crimes of indecency; crimes aggravated by racial or religious hatred; crimes involving the use of firearms; causing death by dangerous driving, or by careless driving under the influence of drink or drugs; and the most serious breaches of the peace and housebreaking offences.

Where the offender is sentenced to four years or more in prison, including life sentences and detention without limit of time, the victim will be given the option to register with the victim notification scheme and to receive this information.

It will normally be the direct victim of the crime who can register but where the direct victim has died, the four nearest relatives are eligible. Where the victim is incapable of registering, or is a child under 14, the nearest relative can register on their behalf.

Full Story

New unit aims to improve frontline policing
A new Business Benefits Unit is to be set up by the Executive and Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland to help forces improve their efficiency and ensure their finances are concentrated on frontline policing.

The unit will seek out savings in back-office functions such as IT and payroll and advise forces on how best to cut red-tape.

A pilot scheme to improve the way police vehicles are sourced and maintained is already under way and is expected to yield savings of £200,000 a year.

Ministers expect the new unit be self-funding after two years and to identify significant savings - all of which can be ploughed into frontline police efforts to prevent and detect crime.

Initially based with ACPOS Secretariat and supported by £288,200 in Executive funding, the unit will:

·         Scrutinise forces' best value reviews to help them improve efficiency and ensure that existing good practice is spread across the country;

·         Develop standard ways of managing back office work such as legal advice, IT support and procurement which will be rolled out across the country and, where appropriate, handled nationally; and

·         Help forces implement and monitor the changes being introduced as part of these reviews, to ensure they are delivering results.

Full Story

 

SECTION 3 - NOTES ON THIS WEEK’S CHAMBER BUSINESS

Wednesday’s Chamber Business begins with a Ministerial Statement and Executive debate on the Spending Review 2004.

The official announcement of the funding which each Executive department is to be allocated, it must be made to Parliament in the first instance and so no information regarding its contents is currently available.


The day concludes with a Member’s Business debate on the Development of Edinburgh Airport from Margaret Smith (LIB DEM).


THURSDAY begins with a Conservative debate on Health Issues.

As is normal with opposition debates, the motion has yet to be published.  However, if press speculation is to be believed, it is likely that the centralisation of services across Scotland could be the focus.

As always, the text of the motion will be published in the Business Bulletin in due course and a full transcript of the debate will be available in the Official Report from Thursday.

 


This is followed by First Minister’s Question Time.


In the afternoon, after Question Time (for the departments featured in the themed section this week, see Section 1 above), the Chamber debates Stage 1 of the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Bill.

This Executive Bill aims to create a specific offence of attacking an emergency worker, or someone assisting an emergency worker, when responding to emergency circumstances, thus providing specific protection for emergency workers.  The Bill, if passed, would also make special provision for health workers in hospital accident and emergency premises, with the effect that a state of emergency would be considered to exist at all times in such places.

In its stage 1 report, the Justice 1 Committee supported the general principles of the Bill (with only Margaret Mitchell (CON) dissenting), stating that it will add, at the margins, to existing common law and statutory provisions which protect emergency workers. However, the Committee does have questions about how the legislation will work in practice.

The Committee pointed out:

·     The Committee was very concerned about the information accompanying the Bill and the lack of clarity in the policy memorandum.

·     Statistical data made available to the Committee to support the policy intentions of the Bill was limited and inconsistent.

·     The Committee does not want offences to be downgraded from solemn (sheriff and jury) to summary proceedings (sheriff only) just because the Bill would allow a higher sentence (up to nine months) in summary court (higher sentences can be, and have been, passed for offences against emergency workers tried under solemn procedure).

·     Recent guidance from the Lord Advocate states that incidents involving attacks on public service workers and others providing a service to the public should be taken seriously and that the locus and the fact that the person is providing a service to the public are both aggravating factors which should be borne in mind by prosecutors in deciding the appropriate forum for the case. The Committee received evidence that this guidance is having a positive impact on how such cases are prosecuted and believes that the Executive should assess the impact of this guidance.

·     The Committee acknowledges that, due to the more complex evidential requirements for the Crown to prove an offence under the Bill than a common law offence of assault, there may potentially be a loss of flexibility for prosecutors.

Click here to read the Bill as introduced
Click here to read the Explanatory Notes
Click here to read the Policy Memorandum


The day is then rounded off with a Member’s Business debate on Increasing Gender Pay Gap from Sandra White (SNP).

 

[ HOME ] [ News ] [ Report to the People ] [ Interact ] [ Links ] [ E-Mail ]

[ Copyright ] [ Directgov ] [ Scottish Parliament ]

Previous Page