Scottish Parliament Committee News
Issue 194, 12th September
2006
Communities
Committee
The Committee continued taking evidence
on the Planning
etc. (Scotland) Bill, hearing from Deputy Environment and Rural
Development Minister, Rhona Brankin, on National Scenic Areas. Deputy
Communities Minister, Johann Lamont, also gave evidence on on Local Authority
interests.
Edinburgh
Airport Rail Link Bill Committee
Enterprise
& Culture Committee
The Committee considered a final report on
external research commissioned on the costs and benefits to the economy of the
various options for celebrating St Andrew’s Day.
It also considered its future work program. It was agreed to commission SPICe to conduct research into the ongoing impact of EU structural funds in Scotland; to hold hearings on progress being made with establishing Creative Scotland and with Workforce Plus before the end of the of the session; and to conduct work on the review of Sport 21.
Environment
and Rural Development Committee
Last week's meeting considered a petition
from the Community of Arran Seabed Trust (COAST) requesting that the Scottish
Parliament support its proposals to close an area of Lamlash Bay to all forms
of marine life extraction (a "No Take Zone") and the rest of the
Bay to mobile fishing gear ("Marine Protected Area"). The
Committee agreed to take oral evidence on the petition at its meeting on 20th
September.
The Committee also agreed to write to the Minister for Environment and Rural Development to seek further information on the impact of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill on sustainable development.
European
and External Relations Committee
A petition calling on the Scottish
Parliament to use its influence to return control over the fishing industry to
Scotland was on the agenda. SNP members positioned themselves in support
of the petition. However, Ben Bradshaw MP, the Fisheries Minister at
Westminster, issued the Committee with a substantial response detailing the
legal position and legal implications of the UK withdrawing from the Common
Fisheries Policy, concluding that you cannot simply withdraw. The
Committee agreed to close the petition.
Finance
Committee
The Committee considered a paper from its
budget adviser, Prof Arthur Midwinter, on a Review of Scottish Executive
Management of Public Finances. The main themes included Pre-Expenditure
Assessments, Best Value and Efficient Government. In oral evidence, Prof
Midwinter stressed the ongoing problem of measuring public sector output for
economic growth purposes.
The Committee considered its draft report on its Accountability and Governance inquiry and will discuss a further draft at its next meeting.
The Committee agreed its draft report on the Financial Memorandum of the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Bill. The Committee accepted that Executive officials had not been in a position to confirm in oral evidence that adequate funding will be provided in the next Spending Review, so suggested in the report that the Health Committee should seek assurances from the Minister as to the specific level of funding which will be provided to local authorities for implementation of the Bill.
Health
Committee
Members took evidence on the Adult
Support and Protection (Scotland) Bill and discussed their approach to
Stage 1 of the Bill.
Justice
1 Committee
William Taylor, Chief inspector of
Constabulary in Scotland, and Jim Wallace, former Minister for Justice, gave
evidence on the Scottish Criminal Record inquiry. They were
followed by Joanne Tierney, Training Manager for the Scottish Fingerprint
Service. The Committee agreed to defer consideration of the main themes
arising from the evidence session to a future meeting and the inquiry continues.
The Committee took evidence on Karen Whitefield's (LAB) Christmas Day and New Year's Day Trading (Scotland) Bill from, among others, shopworkers' union, USDAW; the Scottish Retail Consortium; Edinburgh Woollen Mill; the Co-op; and Debenham's. Further evidence will be taken on what is proving to be a contentious Bill. Much of the opposition centres on tourism issues and the major big city stores and their organisations say that they should be allowed to open of New Year's Day.
Local Government and Transport Committee
Procedures
Committee
The Committee discussed its report on
the Review of the Parliamentary Week. The review has not yet been
concluded.
The Committee began with a petition concerning the proposals for the controversial Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route. The petitioner answered a number of questions from Committee members and other interested MSPs present on why he believed the consultation was unfair and biased, and why he is against the building of any new road. Members agreed to raise his objections and suggestions with Transport Scotland and other transport bodies.
Other petitions considered covered topics including Jetskis near public shores and local authority building warrants.
Subordinate
Legislation Committee
The Committee had a full agenda for its first
meeting of the new session. Items included a number health issues such
as adults with incapacity (removal of regenerative tissue for transplantation);
human tissue and human organs. Justice issues included community
right to buy (definition of excluded land). There were no matters of
concern raised during the meeting which the Committee needed to report to the
Parliament.
Other
Committee Homepages:
Audit Committee
Education Committee
Equal Opportunities Committee
Glasgow Airport Rail Link Bill Committee
Standards Committee
[ HOME ] [ News ] [ Report to the People ] [ Interact ] [ Links ] [ E-Mail ]
[ Copyright ] [ Directgov ] [ Scottish Parliament ]