Scottish Parliament Committee News
Issue 135, 6th July 2004

 

Audit Committee
The Committee heard from the Auditor General for Scotland, Robert Black, on the management of the Holyrood project.  His report criticises the procurement of contracts; the management system used; design changes; risk management procedures; and the leadership of the project as a whole.

Scottish Parliament Chief Executive, Paul Grice, also gave evidence during the marathon session.  Mr Grice’s evidence reflected the context in which we now find ourselves in relation to the building.

 

Education Committee
Last week’s short meeting agreed the visits and meetings in connection with the proposed Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill and the programme for its away day seminar.  The main item of business was the consideration of its final draft report on child protection, which was agreed.

 

Environment and Rural Development Committee
The Committee had a very short meeting where it dealt with various pieces of subordinate legislation and agreed its forward work programme.

 

Equal Opportunities Committee
The Committee heard from the Commission for Racial Equality on the proposed Commission for Equality and Human Rights and considered its approach to the White Paper.

 

Health Committee
Members considered the Draft Stage 1 report on the Breastfeeding etc. (Scotland) Bill. They also considered two petitions from James Mackie and Steve Law on Autism Spectrum Disorder and six other petitions on a variety of Health related issues.

The main item of business was the taking of evidence on the Prohibition of Smoking in Regulated Areas (Scotland) Bill. Evidence came from Dr Nancy Miller, Assistant Commissioner New York Department of Health who told the Committee that the smoking in public places ban had been a great success in New York and there were no problems with its implementation. Tom McCabe, Deputy Minister for Health, was also asked to give evidence. He explained the Executive's position, saying that so far there had been a good response from the general public to the proposals, but that there would be a full public consultation and the Executive would only implement a ban if it had the full backing of the public.

 

Justice 1 Committee
Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Affairs, Allan Wilson, moved that the Justice 1 Committee recommend that the Proposed Scottish Outdoor Access Code be approved. After a short debate, the motion was agreed. The Committee then went on to consider and note a negative instrument - The Victim Statements (Prescribe Offences) Amendment Order 2004.

Further to its meeting on 10th December 2003 which agreed  a proposal for a comparative review of alternatives to custody, the Committee considered an interim report on the review and agreed that the use of alternatives to custody in Finland, Sweden and Western Australia should be examined in more detail in phase two of the research project. The Committee also considered its forward work programme and agreed a timetable for oral evidence in relation to its inquiry into the effectiveness of rehabilitation programmes in prisons. Members also agreed to take evidence from HM Chief Inspector of Prisons on his annual report. With regard to the Civil Partnership Bill, the Committee gave further consideration to its approach to the Bill and agreed to write to the Minister for Justice seeking clarification in relation to the Sewel process.

 

Justice 2 Committee
The Committee dealt with subordinate legislation, correspondence on Cornton Vale prison and went into private session to consider its approach to the Fire (Scotland) Bill. On the Cornton Vale issue, the Committee agreed to advise the correspondent to write to her constituency or list MSP about her concerns.

 

Local Government and Transport Committee
Private consideration of a draft report on the rail industry in
Scotland was followed by evidence on the Inquiry into issues arising from the Transport (Scotland) Act 2001. The Committee also considered a paper on petition PE568 by Douglas Gilroy on the provision of accessible taxis.

 

Public Petitions Committee
The Committee considered six new petitions including one that called for the standardisation of school holidays across Scotland. This petition came to light following a written answer from Jack McConnell when he was Education Secretary which implied that the Executive was considering it as an option at that time. The Committee will write to CoSLA and to the Executive to ask if there has been any further discussion or debate on the matter. It also looked at a number of current petitions, including one calling for an inquiry into past institutional child abuse. The first petition on this issue had been lodged 4 years ago and no satisfactory conclusion had been reached and this second petition has also failed to reach a satisfactory conclusion. Accordingly, the Committee has invited Education and Young People Minister, Peter Peacock, to attend its next meeting and put forward the Executive's position. Another petition calling for an inquiry into health aspects of Gulf War Syndrome had only received a holding reply. The Committee was not happy with this situation and has written to Malcolm Chisholm as Minister responsible asking for a full explanation.

 

Standards Committee
It was decided that Tricia Marwick (SNP) and Kenny MacAskill (SNP) did not breach parliamentary rules in relation to a complaint relating to information they held on constituents.  The Committee published its report on the complaint last week which records its unanimous decision that the complaint should not be upheld.

 

Subordinate Legislation Committee
Convener, Sylvia Jackson (LAB) reported back on her appearance on behalf of the Subordinate Legislation Committee before the Environment and Rural Development Committee regarding Subordinate Legislation’s findings in relation to the Environmental Protection (Restriction on Use of Lead Shot) Scotland regulations 2004. The Committee had raised many points on the Regulations, including serious questions of vires. The Committee considered the Executive's response in detail, but agreed that it fails properly to address any of the Committee's points. The Committee was particularly concerned that the issues arising were not only technical detail, but important matters of civil liberties. Indeed, there were so many issues of concern to the Committee that it felt the Regulations failed to comply with proper legislative practice and it could not agree to them in their current form. It was suggested that the Environment Committee should look at the Regulations again.

 

Other Committee Homepages:

Communities Committee
Enterprise & Culture Committee
European and External Relations Committee
Finance Committee
Procedures Committee

 

[ HOME ] [ News ] [ Report to the People ] [ Interact ] [ Links ] [ E-Mail ]

[ Copyright ] [ Directgov ] [ Scottish Parliament ]

Previous Page